The artisanal craft of overthinking
Carl is questioning the economics of making things. I’m questioning the psychology of making things. There’s an unfortunate overlap. We are both beginning to distrust a creative culture that has become very good at producing things and increasingly confused about why. We’re hardly pioneers, just observers. The tools have never been better. I'm not sure anyone is having more fun.
When I grew up, only artists had creative personal projects. Everyone else had hobbies. Today, just about everyone I know is making something. The independent creator has become something of an institution, complete with its own expectations, anxieties, and little rituals. Carl still believes in creative work, but he's losing faith in the systems through which it is valued. I've never assumed that care and craftsmanship would necessarily translate into value. None of the things I made as a kid had much artistic value. Nobody pretended otherwise. But we meet somewhere else: creative work has become easier to produce, harder to value, and more important to our identities.
My therapist pointed out that my blog is a rather blatant example of that contradiction. I have no audience to satisfy and nothing to sell. And yet I somehow managed to turn myself into a creative project. I’m a vulgar technician who occasionally, out of boredom and obsession, breaks a rule or two. With visuals and words. I envy the uncomplicated relationship native English speakers have with their language. French felt torturous. Writing in English seemed an unlikely hobby. Whatever the language, good writing is good thinking. I assumed.
I realized I had attempted to turn self-examination into a creative pursuit. What began as an attempt to exorcise gradually became an exercise in cultivating the very traits I was supposedly examining. There's something satisfying about turning every observation, frustration, and contradiction into a little story. Whether that's preferable to remaining blissfully unaware, I'm not entirely sure. I suspect the distinction gets blurrier the more I enjoy the process.
I've noticed something similar with meditation. The pursuit of awareness can become another elaborate preoccupation with oneself. You begin by trying to get out of your own way and end up taking an almost professional interest in the hiccups. Look how long I can stretch that exhale. I've spent an unreasonable amount of time reading about consciousness, hoping to think my way out of thinking. My writing followed much the same pattern. What began as a way to dispose of unwanted thoughts became another way of nurturing them. There's a point at which examining an experience becomes less useful than having it. Which would be artistically acceptable if I didn't occasionally end up more interested in understanding my own behavior than in changing it.
Even this absurd note doesn’t defeat the test of “then you die.” I owe France a ridiculous standard of intellectual honesty. Sitting through Montaigne at age 16 does something. Perhaps the sheer absurdity of civilized life has kept rationality from ever fully gripping my skull. I like to believe it created a buffer in the mind for emotions. A white space more akin to Homer Simpson's cymbal monkey than the quiet monk sitting on a mountain.